Player of the Year

Scarborough Evening News Player of the Year

07-08  Scott Phillips

08-09  Dave Hartas

09-10  Dave Kemp

Scarborough Athletic FC Supporters Club Supporters' Player of the Year

07-08  Dave Thompson

08-09   Ryan Blott

09-10   Scott Phillips

SAFC SC Away Player of the Year

07-08  Dave Thompson

08-09   Dave Hartas

09-10   Joel Hartley

Norwegian Seadogs Player of the Year

07-08  Scott Phillips